• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Headwaters Economics

Headwaters Economics

Independent Nonpartisan Research

  • Research
    • Economic Development
    • Equity
    • Natural Hazards
    • Public Lands
    • Outdoor Recreation
    • Tax Policy
  • Tools
  • About Us
  • Search
Credit: Amelia Templeton/Copyright OPB

Fiscal policy is failing rural America

October 2020

Fiscal policies are a powerful tool for economic development. Unfortunately, fiscal policies have failed rural communities in two ways. First, they have created a dependence on a narrow set of industries, such as fossil fuels. Second, fiscal policies have constrained the ability of local governments to grow and invest revenues in ways aligned with economic diversification.

For example, local governments in Utah have every incentive to support fossil fuel development over renewable energy because of the state’s tax policies that disallow local governments from retaining revenue from new wind and solar projects. By comparison, oil and natural gas revenue is exempt from the limits placed on renewable energy, so local budgets can soar when oil prices and production are high.

In this essay we discuss how fiscal policies constrain rural America. We discuss the broad fiscal challenges facing rural communities, using examples of public lands and renewable energy as two areas where rural communities can benefit from economic opportunities but where fiscal policies create barriers to realizing revenue benefits.

Why we wrote this:
Fiscal policies that fail communities are not accidental: many have been deliberately designed to impede diversified rural economic development and to eliminate the revenue benefit of public land conservation or the transition to renewable energy.

By fiscal policy, we mean the ways that governments generate revenue from economic activity—from taxes, fees for services, and royalties on resource extraction, for example—and how governments use these revenues to pay for services such as roads, schools, police, and hospitals.

Download Essay
Published on October 28, 2020Posted under Economic DevelopmentTags: coal fiscal policies, public lands, renewable energy, state fiscal policy, Tax Policy
Author:
Mark Haggerty

For more information about this topic contact:

Kelly Pohl
  • 406.599.7841
  • kelly@headwaterseconomics.org

Related Research

Why fiscal policy solutions are necessary
Solutions for Transitioning Coal-Dependent Communities
Split image with trucks driving down into coal mine on one side and wind turbines atop a green hill at sunset on the other. The Evolution of U.S. Electricity Generation Capacity
Headwaters-staff-Mark-Haggerty Getting Real About Rural Resilience

Footer

Independent Nonpartisan Research

Contact

© 2023 Headwaters Economics, all rights reserved

  • Sitemap
  • Terms of Use
  • Photo Credits
  • Media Coverage
  • Slides
  • Contact
  • Twitter