• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Headwaters Economics

Headwaters Economics

Independent Nonpartisan Research

  • Research
    • Economic Development
    • Equity
    • Natural Hazards
    • Public Lands
    • Outdoor Recreation
    • Tax Policy
  • Tools
  • About Us
  • Search

Western Counties and the Recession

September 2012

Our full report, “The Recession and the New Economy of the West” (1.5M PDF), analyzed all 413 counties in the 11 contiguous western states. We focused on the factors contributing to growth in the 1990s and 2000s, and why some local economies performed better than others during the recent recession.

The journal Growth and Change published this study in their September 2012 issue. It was summarized in our Op-Ed, “West’s most diverse economies weather recession best”, in the Billings Gazette and other newspapers.

These are some of our findings:

Lessons

Lesson 1: The faster a county’s population grew from 2000 to 2007, on average, the faster the area tended to lose jobs during the recession.
Map: Western Counties Unemployment Rate 2007-2009

Lesson 2: Counties that were more timber dependent tended to lose jobs at a faster rate during the recession.
Scatter plot: Western Counties- Timber JobsMap: Western Counties- Timber Jobs 2007-2009
Lesson 3: On average, counties with higher education rates (the percent of adults with a college degree) experienced lower rates of job loss.
Scatter plot: Western Counties- College Degrees 2007-2009Map: Western Counties- College Degrees 2007-2009
Lesson 4: Higher government employment was also associated with lower rates of job loss.
Map: Western Counties- Government Jobs 2007-2009

Government employment was found to be beneficial in that, after controlling for pre-recession unemployment and population levels, higher government employment, including military, federal, state and local government, was associated with lower rates of job loss.

The results of this study underscore important tenets of economic development in a modern economy:

  1. The importance of education in the emerging global economy,
  2. The stabilizing effect of government employment during economic contraction, and
  3. The dangers of over-reliance on single sectors, in particular those that fluctuate with commodity markets, such as the timber industry.

The full report, “The Recession and the New Economy of the West” (1.5M PDF), contains extensive statistics and sources.

Related Visualization

Related data visualizationDataViz

Resources

Recession Paper (PDF)

Billings Gazette Op-Ed

Published on September 20, 2012Posted under Economic DevelopmentTags: Economic Development, Trends & Performance

Ray Rasker, Ph.D.

  rayrasker@gmail.com       406.570.7044

Ray is the co-founder and former Executive Director of Headwaters Economics. Ray retired in 2021 and can be reached at rayrasker@gmail.com or 406 570-7044

Related Research

map of how protected public lands increase per capita income Protected Federal Lands in Non-Metro West Increase Per Capita Income
Long-Term Energy Development Has Negative Impacts on Western Counties
Non-Labor Income: Large and Growing in Importance Across the West
uhaul trucks Migration & Population Trends in the West Vary by County Type

Footer

Independent Nonpartisan Research

Contact

© 2023 Headwaters Economics, all rights reserved

  • Sitemap
  • Terms of Use
  • Photo Credits
  • Media Coverage
  • Slides
  • Contact
  • Twitter
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.